Aide Brut Harmonisation Luxey Comparaison
Dégustation LPV
03/04/2005
Vin\DegB.BAH.BIA.BRD.COF.DLXS.DED.DUE.EVJC.FXL.JAB.LGV.NOJ.PéP.RAD.SEF.SUD.THC.VIY.ZEMoyRangEcart
Vin\DegB.BAH.BIA.BRD.COF.DLXS.DED.DUE.EVJC.FXL.JAB.LGV.NOJ.PéP.RAD.SEF.SUD.THC.VIY.ZEMoyRangEcart
104.0
4
5.0
1
4.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
3.0
12
4.0
4
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
4
5.0
1
5.0
1
3.0
4
5.0
1
4.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
4.610.66USASine Qua NonMidnight Oil2001
213.0
13
2.0
17
3.0
12
4.0
3
2.0
13
4.0
4
4.0
4
5.0
1
4.0
3
4.0
2
4.0
4
4.0
5
2.0
16
2.0
14
5.0
1
 5.0
1
2.0
20
3.0
9
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.561.02Saint-EmilionChâteau Pavie-Macquin 2001
13.0
13
2.0
17
3.0
12
3.0
7
4.0
4
3.0
12
3.0
8
4.0
12
3.0
13
4.0
2
5.0
1
4.0
5
3.0
6
2.0
14
3.0
13
4.0
1
4.0
3
2.0
20
3.0
9
3.0
21
3.0
6
3.2120.75USAArchery Summit EstateOregon Pinot Noir2001
113.0
13
3.0
13
4.0
1
2.0
20
5.0
1
4.0
4
2.0
16
4.0
12
4.0
3
4.0
2
3.0
15
4.0
5
4.0
4
4.0
1
4.0
4
4.0
1
4.0
3
4.0
7
2.0
20
3.0
21
4.0
4
3.650.79CornasDomaine AllemandReynard2001
152.0
22
1.0
24
4.0
1
4.0
3
3.0
9
4.0
4
1.0
23
4.0
12
4.0
3
4.0
2
5.0
1
3.0
19
1.0
26
3.0
4
4.0
4
3.0
8
4.0
3
5.0
1
3.0
9
4.0
5
2.0
19
3.2121.19ArgentineAchaval FerrerFinca Altamira2002
234.0
4
5.0
1
4.0
1
3.0
7
4.0
4
3.0
12
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
3.0
10
3.0
15
4.0
5
2.0
16
3.0
4
3.0
13
 4.0
3
4.0
7
4.0
4
5.0
1
3.0
6
3.840.87ChiliCasa LapostolleClos Apalta2001
42.0
22
4.0
7
2.0
17
3.0
7
2.0
13
2.0
19
2.0
16
3.0
22
4.0
3
4.0
2
4.0
4
3.0
19
2.0
16
2.0
14
3.0
13
4.0
1
3.0
7
3.0
16
3.0
9
3.0
21
3.0
6
2.9200.75Nuits Saint-GeorgesDomaine Henri GougesLes Saints-Georges2001
6 1.0
24
2.0
17
2.0
20
1.0
27
5.0
1
1.0
23
3.0
22
2.0
26
2.0
15
4.0
4
1.0
27
1.0
26
1.0
23
2.0
21
2.0
14
3.0
7
2.0
20
1.0
26
4.0
5
2.0
19
2.1271.14Vin de Pays d'OcDomaine LissonClos du Curé2001
143.0
13
 4.0
1
3.0
7
2.0
13
3.0
12
2.0
16
4.0
12
3.0
13
2.0
15
4.0
4
3.0
19
3.0
6
3.0
4
4.0
4
3.0
8
3.0
7
4.0
7
3.0
9
4.0
5
2.0
19
3.1160.70CahorsDomaine de LagrezetteLe Pigeonnier2001
163.0
13
2.0
17
4.0
1
3.0
7
2.0
13
3.0
12
2.0
16
5.0
1
3.0
13
3.0
10
3.0
15
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.0
4
3.0
13
4.0
1
3.0
7
5.0
1
3.0
9
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.2120.81CahorsChâteau du CèdreGrand Cru2001
173.0
13
3.0
13
2.0
17
2.0
20
2.0
13
2.0
19
2.0
16
4.0
12
3.0
13
2.0
15
4.0
4
4.0
5
2.0
16
3.0
4
4.0
4
2.0
14
3.0
7
1.0
27
2.0
20
4.0
5
2.0
19
2.7220.89Saint-JulienChâteau Léoville Barton 2001
182.0
22
2.0
17
2.0
17
2.0
20
2.0
13
2.0
19
2.0
16
4.0
12
3.0
13
2.0
15
4.0
4
3.0
19
2.0
16
2.0
14
3.0
13
2.0
14
3.0
7
4.0
7
3.0
9
4.0
5
3.0
6
2.7220.78MargauxChâteau Kirwan 2001
194.0
4
4.0
7
3.0
12
3.0
7
2.0
13
2.0
19
3.0
8
4.0
12
3.0
13
4.0
2
3.0
15
3.0
19
3.0
6
4.0
1
4.0
4
2.0
14
3.0
7
4.0
7
3.0
9
4.0
5
2.0
19
3.2120.73Vin de Pays d'OcMas de Daumas GassacCuvée Emile Peynaud2001
204.0
4
4.0
7
2.0
17
4.0
3
3.0
9
4.0
4
4.0
4
5.0
1
2.0
26
2.0
15
3.0
15
4.0
5
4.0
4
3.0
4
4.0
4
 3.0
7
2.0
20
4.0
4
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.480.86USAStag’s Leap Wine CellarsCask 232001
224.0
4
5.0
1
4.0
1
3.0
7
2.0
13
4.0
4
3.0
8
5.0
1
3.0
13
3.0
10
3.0
15
4.0
5
3.0
6
2.0
14
3.0
13
 3.0
7
5.0
1
3.0
9
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.560.86ItalieTenuta dell’OrnellaiaOrnellaia2001
254.0
4
4.0
7
2.0
17
3.0
7
4.0
4
4.0
4
3.0
8
5.0
1
3.0
13
1.0
25
4.0
4
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.0
4
2.0
21
 3.0
7
4.0
7
4.0
4
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.480.91USARidge MontebelloCabernet Sauvignon2001
24.0
4
2.0
17
3.0
12
3.0
7
2.0
13
5.0
1
3.0
8
3.0
22
4.0
3
2.0
15
4.0
4
4.0
5
3.0
6
2.0
14
4.0
4
4.0
1
2.0
17
3.0
16
2.0
20
2.0
26
5.0
1
3.1160.99USALandmarkKastania Vineyard Pinot Noir2001
32.0
22
3.0
13
2.0
17
2.0
20
2.0
13
3.0
12
2.0
16
3.0
22
3.0
13
1.0
25
3.0
15
4.0
5
2.0
16
1.0
23
2.0
21
2.0
14
2.0
17
3.0
16
2.0
20
1.0
27
2.0
19
2.2260.75PommardDomaine De MontilleRugiens2001
55.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
4
5.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
3
2.0
15
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
1
5.0
1
3.0
8
2.0
17
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
4.420.95Morey Saint-DenisDomaine du Clos de TartClos de Tart2001
73.0
13
2.0
17
3.0
12
3.0
7
2.0
13
2.0
19
4.0
4
3.0
22
3.0
13
4.0
2
3.0
15
4.0
5
2.0
16
 2.0
21
2.0
14
2.0
17
4.0
7
4.0
4
4.0
5
3.0
6
3180.80Saint-ChinianDomaine MoulinierTerrasses Grillées2001
85.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
1
3.0
7
3.0
9
2.0
19
 5.0
1
4.0
3
2.0
15
4.0
4
3.0
19
3.0
6
3.0
4
3.0
13
3.0
8
2.0
17
3.0
16
3.0
9
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.480.91Côte RôtieDomaine GuigalLa Mouline2001
93.0
13
 1.0
27
4.0
3
2.0
13
5.0
1
1.0
23
4.0
12
3.0
13
1.0
25
2.0
27
2.0
25
3.0
6
1.0
23
3.0
13
2.0
14
2.0
17
2.0
20
2.0
20
3.0
21
3.0
6
2.5241.07AustralieClarendon HillsSyrah Moritz Vineyard2002
123.0
13
4.0
7
2.0
17
3.0
7
4.0
4
2.0
19
3.0
8
5.0
1
3.0
13
2.0
15
3.0
15
5.0
1
2.0
16
2.0
14
2.0
21
3.0
8
2.0
17
2.0
20
3.0
9
3.0
21
2.0
19
2.9200.94ArgentineVal de FloresMendoza2002
132.0
22
3.0
13
4.0
1
2.0
20
2.0
13
2.0
19
3.0
8
4.0
12
3.0
13
3.0
10
4.0
4
4.0
5
3.0
6
2.0
14
4.0
4
3.0
8
2.0
17
4.0
7
2.0
20
4.0
5
2.0
19
3180.84CahorsDomaine Cosse-MaisonneuveLes Laquets2001
244.0
4
4.0
7
2.0
17
3.0
7
4.0
4
3.0
12
3.0
8
5.0
1
4.0
3
4.0
2
3.0
15
5.0
1
5.0
1
2.0
14
4.0
4
4.0
1
 5.0
1
5.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
4
3.930.94USAStaglin FamilyCabernet Sauvignon2001
264.0
4
2.0
17
2.0
17
 3.0
9
4.0
4
1.0
23
3.0
22
4.0
3
3.0
10
3.0
15
2.0
25
2.0
16
1.0
23
2.0
21
  2.0
20
1.0
26
4.0
5
2.0
19
2.5241.01Vin de Pays d'OcDomaine LissonLes échelles de Lisson2001
275.0
1
5.0
1
4.0
1
2.0
20
2.0
13
 5.0
1
4.0
12
4.0
3
2.0
15
3.0
15
4.0
5
2.0
16
3.0
4
2.0
21
  4.0
7
4.0
4
4.0
5
3.0
6
3.481.07Saint-EmilionChâteau Valandraud 2001
Moy3.43.3332.83.22.84.23.42.83.63.72.82.53.3333.433.83
Ecart0.91.310.91.111.20.80.71.10.70.91.10.910.80.91.21.10.90.9

Les dégustateurs

1BaillarguetBrunocaviste Vignobles et Châteaux et hôte de la dégustation
2BizeulHervéDomaine du Clos des Fées
3BradferAlainécrivain
4CobboldDavidjournaliste
5Des LignerisFrançoisChâteau Soutard
6X
7DerenoncourtStéphaneDomaine de l’A et œnologue consultant
8DupontDidier 
9EvreuxEric 
10FauréJean-Claude 
11X
12JavauxLuc 
13Le GuernBertrand 
14NoceVincentjournaliste Libération
15PérezJérôme 
16RapiteauPhilippe 
17SeriotDaniel 
18SuquetFabien 
19ThibautDidier 
20VillaretClaude 
21ZermattenYves