Aide | Brut | Harmonisation | Luxey | Comparaison |
Vin\Deg | B.BA | H.BI | A.BR | D.CO | F.DL | X | S.DE | D.DU | E.EV | JC.F | X | L.JA | B.LG | V.NO | J.Pé | P.RA | D.SE | F.SU | D.TH | C.VI | Y.ZE | Moy | Rang | Ecart | ||||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vin\Deg | B.BA | H.BI | A.BR | D.CO | F.DL | X | S.DE | D.DU | E.EV | JC.F | X | L.JA | B.LG | V.NO | J.Pé | P.RA | D.SE | F.SU | D.TH | C.VI | Y.ZE | Moy | Rang | Ecart | ||||
10 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 12 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.6 | 1 | 0.66 | USA | Sine Qua Non | Midnight Oil | 2001 |
1 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 12 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 12 | 3.0 8 | 4.0 12 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 2 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 1 | 4.0 3 | 2.0 20 | 3.0 9 | 3.0 21 | 3.0 6 | 3.2 | 12 | 0.75 | USA | Archery Summit Estate | Oregon Pinot Noir | 2001 |
4 | 2.0 22 | 4.0 7 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 13 | 2.0 19 | 2.0 16 | 3.0 22 | 4.0 3 | 4.0 2 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 19 | 2.0 16 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 1 | 3.0 7 | 3.0 16 | 3.0 9 | 3.0 21 | 3.0 6 | 2.9 | 20 | 0.75 | Nuits Saint-Georges | Domaine Henri Gouges | Les Saints-Georges | 2001 |
7 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 12 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 13 | 2.0 19 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 22 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 2 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 16 | 2.0 21 | 2.0 14 | 2.0 17 | 4.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3 | 18 | 0.80 | Saint-Chinian | Domaine Moulinier | Terrasses Grillées | 2001 | |
11 | 3.0 13 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 1 | 2.0 20 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 4 | 2.0 16 | 4.0 12 | 4.0 3 | 4.0 2 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 1 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 1 | 4.0 3 | 4.0 7 | 2.0 20 | 3.0 21 | 4.0 4 | 3.6 | 5 | 0.79 | Cornas | Domaine Allemand | Reynard | 2001 |
15 | 2.0 22 | 1.0 24 | 4.0 1 | 4.0 3 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 4 | 1.0 23 | 4.0 12 | 4.0 3 | 4.0 2 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 19 | 1.0 26 | 3.0 4 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 8 | 4.0 3 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 19 | 3.2 | 12 | 1.19 | Argentine | Achaval Ferrer | Finca Altamira | 2002 |
19 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 7 | 3.0 12 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 13 | 2.0 19 | 3.0 8 | 4.0 12 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 2 | 3.0 15 | 3.0 19 | 3.0 6 | 4.0 1 | 4.0 4 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 7 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 19 | 3.2 | 12 | 0.73 | Vin de Pays d'Oc | Mas de Daumas Gassac | Cuvée Emile Peynaud | 2001 |
21 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 12 | 4.0 3 | 2.0 13 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 3 | 4.0 2 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 16 | 2.0 14 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 2.0 20 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.5 | 6 | 1.02 | Saint-Emilion | Château Pavie-Macquin | 2001 | ||
24 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 7 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 12 | 3.0 8 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 3 | 4.0 2 | 3.0 15 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 2.0 14 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 4 | 3.9 | 3 | 0.94 | USA | Staglin Family | Cabernet Sauvignon | 2001 | |
13 | 2.0 22 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 1 | 2.0 20 | 2.0 13 | 2.0 19 | 3.0 8 | 4.0 12 | 3.0 13 | 3.0 10 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 2.0 14 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 8 | 2.0 17 | 4.0 7 | 2.0 20 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 19 | 3 | 18 | 0.84 | Cahors | Domaine Cosse-Maisonneuve | Les Laquets | 2001 |
16 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 17 | 4.0 1 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 13 | 3.0 12 | 2.0 16 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 13 | 3.0 10 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.0 4 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 1 | 3.0 7 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.2 | 12 | 0.81 | Cahors | Château du Cèdre | Grand Cru | 2001 |
22 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 13 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 8 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 13 | 3.0 10 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 13 | 3.0 7 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.5 | 6 | 0.86 | Italie | Tenuta dell’Ornellaia | Ornellaia | 2001 | |
23 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 12 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 10 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 16 | 3.0 4 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 3 | 4.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 6 | 3.8 | 4 | 0.87 | Chili | Casa Lapostolle | Clos Apalta | 2001 | |
26 | 4.0 4 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 4 | 1.0 23 | 3.0 22 | 4.0 3 | 3.0 10 | 3.0 15 | 2.0 25 | 2.0 16 | 1.0 23 | 2.0 21 | 2.0 20 | 1.0 26 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 19 | 2.5 | 24 | 1.01 | Vin de Pays d'Oc | Domaine Lisson | Les échelles de Lisson | 2001 | |||
2 | 4.0 4 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 12 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 13 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 8 | 3.0 22 | 4.0 3 | 2.0 15 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 2.0 14 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 1 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 16 | 2.0 20 | 2.0 26 | 5.0 1 | 3.1 | 16 | 0.99 | USA | Landmark | Kastania Vineyard Pinot Noir | 2001 |
5 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 3 | 2.0 15 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 8 | 2.0 17 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.4 | 2 | 0.95 | Morey Saint-Denis | Domaine du Clos de Tart | Clos de Tart | 2001 |
6 | 1.0 24 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 20 | 1.0 27 | 5.0 1 | 1.0 23 | 3.0 22 | 2.0 26 | 2.0 15 | 4.0 4 | 1.0 27 | 1.0 26 | 1.0 23 | 2.0 21 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 20 | 1.0 26 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 19 | 2.1 | 27 | 1.14 | Vin de Pays d'Oc | Domaine Lisson | Clos du Curé | 2001 | |
8 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 3.0 7 | 3.0 9 | 2.0 19 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 3 | 2.0 15 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 19 | 3.0 6 | 3.0 4 | 3.0 13 | 3.0 8 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 16 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.4 | 8 | 0.91 | Côte Rôtie | Domaine Guigal | La Mouline | 2001 | |
12 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 7 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 2.0 19 | 3.0 8 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 15 | 3.0 15 | 5.0 1 | 2.0 16 | 2.0 14 | 2.0 21 | 3.0 8 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 20 | 3.0 9 | 3.0 21 | 2.0 19 | 2.9 | 20 | 0.94 | Argentine | Val de Flores | Mendoza | 2002 |
14 | 3.0 13 | 4.0 1 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 13 | 3.0 12 | 2.0 16 | 4.0 12 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 15 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 19 | 3.0 6 | 3.0 4 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 8 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 7 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 19 | 3.1 | 16 | 0.70 | Cahors | Domaine de Lagrezette | Le Pigeonnier | 2001 | |
17 | 3.0 13 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 20 | 2.0 13 | 2.0 19 | 2.0 16 | 4.0 12 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 15 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 16 | 3.0 4 | 4.0 4 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 7 | 1.0 27 | 2.0 20 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 19 | 2.7 | 22 | 0.89 | Saint-Julien | Château Léoville Barton | 2001 | |
18 | 2.0 22 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 20 | 2.0 13 | 2.0 19 | 2.0 16 | 4.0 12 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 15 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 19 | 2.0 16 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 14 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 7 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 2.7 | 22 | 0.78 | Margaux | Château Kirwan | 2001 | |
20 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 7 | 2.0 17 | 4.0 3 | 3.0 9 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 4 | 5.0 1 | 2.0 26 | 2.0 15 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 4 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 7 | 2.0 20 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.4 | 8 | 0.86 | USA | Stag’s Leap Wine Cellars | Cask 23 | 2001 | |
27 | 5.0 1 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 1 | 2.0 20 | 2.0 13 | 5.0 1 | 4.0 12 | 4.0 3 | 2.0 15 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 16 | 3.0 4 | 2.0 21 | 4.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.4 | 8 | 1.07 | Saint-Emilion | Château Valandraud | 2001 | ||||
3 | 2.0 22 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 20 | 2.0 13 | 3.0 12 | 2.0 16 | 3.0 22 | 3.0 13 | 1.0 25 | 3.0 15 | 4.0 5 | 2.0 16 | 1.0 23 | 2.0 21 | 2.0 14 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 16 | 2.0 20 | 1.0 27 | 2.0 19 | 2.2 | 26 | 0.75 | Pommard | Domaine De Montille | Rugiens | 2001 |
9 | 3.0 13 | 1.0 27 | 4.0 3 | 2.0 13 | 5.0 1 | 1.0 23 | 4.0 12 | 3.0 13 | 1.0 25 | 2.0 27 | 2.0 25 | 3.0 6 | 1.0 23 | 3.0 13 | 2.0 14 | 2.0 17 | 2.0 20 | 2.0 20 | 3.0 21 | 3.0 6 | 2.5 | 24 | 1.07 | Australie | Clarendon Hills | Syrah Moritz Vineyard | 2002 | |
25 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 7 | 2.0 17 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 4 | 3.0 8 | 5.0 1 | 3.0 13 | 1.0 25 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.0 4 | 2.0 21 | 3.0 7 | 4.0 7 | 4.0 4 | 4.0 5 | 3.0 6 | 3.4 | 8 | 0.91 | USA | Ridge Montebello | Cabernet Sauvignon | 2001 | |
Moy | 3.4 | 3.3 | 3 | 3 | 2.8 | 3.2 | 2.8 | 4.2 | 3.4 | 2.8 | 3.6 | 3.7 | 2.8 | 2.5 | 3.3 | 3 | 3 | 3.4 | 3 | 3.8 | 3 | |||||||
Ecart | 0.9 | 1.3 | 1 | 0.9 | 1.1 | 1 | 1.2 | 0.8 | 0.7 | 1.1 | 0.7 | 0.9 | 1.1 | 0.9 | 1 | 0.8 | 0.9 | 1.2 | 1.1 | 0.9 | 0.9 |
1 | Baillarguet | Bruno | caviste Vignobles et Châteaux et hôte de la dégustation |
---|---|---|---|
2 | Bizeul | Hervé | Domaine du Clos des Fées |
3 | Bradfer | Alain | écrivain |
4 | Cobbold | David | journaliste |
5 | Des Ligneris | François | Château Soutard |
6 | X | ||
7 | Derenoncourt | Stéphane | Domaine de l’A et œnologue consultant |
8 | Dupont | Didier | |
9 | Evreux | Eric | |
10 | Fauré | Jean-Claude | |
11 | X | ||
12 | Javaux | Luc | |
13 | Le Guern | Bertrand | |
14 | Noce | Vincent | journaliste Libération |
15 | Pérez | Jérôme | |
16 | Rapiteau | Philippe | |
17 | Seriot | Daniel | |
18 | Suquet | Fabien | |
19 | Thibaut | Didier | |
20 | Villaret | Claude | |
21 | Zermatten | Yves |