Aide | Brut | Harmonisation | Luxey | Comparaison |
SAINT-EMILION 1986
01/10/1990
01/10/1990
Vin\Deg | B.LG | D.HA | D.RI | D.GA | Y.LA | A.SE | JM.J | J.FR | M.DE | A.RO | P.CA | JL.T | Moy | Rang | Ecart | ||
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
Vin\Deg | B.LG | D.HA | D.RI | D.GA | Y.LA | A.SE | JM.J | J.FR | M.DE | A.RO | P.CA | JL.T | Moy | Rang | Ecart | ||
9 | 75.0 2 | 81.0 2 | 64.0 5 | 74.0 7 | 83.0 4 | 74.5 11 | 74.0 2 | 78.0 3 | 76.0 2 | 63.0 13 | 59.0 13 | 81.0 1 | 73.5 | 3 | 7.32 | PAVIE | Saint-Emilion |
12 | 76.0 1 | 83.0 1 | 63.0 6 | 73.0 8 | 70.0 11 | 90.0 1 | 73.0 3 | 82.0 1 | 71.0 7 | 62.0 18 | 65.5 4 | 80.0 2 | 74 | 1 | 8.19 | LA DOMINIQUE | Saint-Emilion |
7 | 71.0 13 | 66.5 20 | 52.0 19 | 72.0 10 | 70.0 11 | 85.0 6 | 61.0 14 | 80.0 2 | 57.0 19 | 62.0 18 | 63.0 6 | 77.0 3 | 68 | 9 | 9.27 | LAROQUE | Saint-Emilion |
18 | 73.0 6 | 65.5 21 | 53.0 16 | 51.0 23 | 62.0 21 | 77.0 9 | 55.0 19 | 58.0 13 | 71.0 7 | 77.0 1 | 49.0 22 | 77.0 3 | 64 | 14 | 10.31 | MAGDELAINE | Saint-Emilion |
14 | 71.0 13 | 79.5 5 | 65.0 3 | 73.0 8 | 79.0 5 | 88.0 2 | 73.0 3 | 78.0 3 | 74.0 3 | 68.0 4 | 63.0 6 | 76.0 5 | 74 | 1 | 6.58 | CANON | Saint-Emilion |
19 | 74.0 3 | 69.0 17 | 53.0 16 | 79.5 5 | 86.0 2 | 80.0 8 | 53.0 23 | 69.0 7 | 73.5 6 | 63.0 13 | 59.0 13 | 76.0 5 | 69.6 | 6 | 10.24 | LARMANDE | Saint-Emilion |
10 | 73.0 6 | 76.0 7 | 54.0 14 | 63.0 13 | 77.0 6 | 56.5 23 | 66.0 7 | 45.0 22 | 68.0 10 | 76.0 2 | 62.0 8 | 75.0 7 | 66 | 11 | 9.81 | HAUT-SARPE | Saint-Emilion |
15 | 66.0 21 | 77.5 6 | 44.0 24 | 50.5 24 | 70.0 11 | 58.0 21 | 62.0 13 | 45.0 22 | 56.0 20 | 65.0 8 | 67.0 2 | 75.0 7 | 61.3 | 21 | 10.47 | FIGEAC | Saint-Emilion |
23 | 72.0 9 | 80.5 3 | 59.0 8 | 80.0 4 | 84.0 3 | 86.5 4 | 64.0 8 | 75.0 6 | 74.0 3 | 65.0 8 | 61.0 9 | 75.0 7 | 73 | 4 | 8.68 | L'ANGELUS | Saint-Emilion |
24 | 74.0 3 | 70.5 14 | 55.0 12 | 81.5 3 | 88.0 1 | 77.0 9 | 55.0 19 | 58.0 13 | 71.0 7 | 62.0 18 | 55.0 16 | 75.0 7 | 68.5 | 8 | 10.81 | CLOS-DES-JACOBINS | Saint-Emilion |
16 | 69.0 18 | 71.0 12 | 65.0 3 | 52.0 19 | 70.0 11 | 72.5 12 | 63.0 11 | 69.0 7 | 60.0 16 | 63.0 13 | 61.0 9 | 74.0 11 | 65.8 | 12 | 6.06 | LE TERTRE ROTEBOEUF | Saint-Emilion |
17 | 74.0 3 | 80.0 4 | 72.0 1 | 76.0 6 | 74.0 7 | 56.5 23 | 76.0 1 | 55.0 16 | 77.0 1 | 66.0 7 | 53.0 18 | 73.0 12 | 69.4 | 7 | 9.01 | LA COUSPAUDE (1987) | Saint-Emilion |
20 | 66.0 21 | 73.5 8 | 68.0 2 | 52.0 19 | 72.0 9 | 70.0 13 | 56.0 18 | 48.0 21 | 63.0 14 | 65.0 8 | 64.0 5 | 73.0 12 | 64.2 | 13 | 7.94 | CANON-LA GAFFELIERE | Saint-Emilion |
3 | 71.0 13 | 70.0 16 | 52.0 19 | 56.5 16 | 64.0 19 | 63.5 16 | 68.0 5 | 69.0 7 | 65.0 12 | 65.0 8 | 50.0 21 | 72.0 14 | 63.8 | 15 | 7.00 | DASSAULT | Saint-Emilion |
8 | 71.0 13 | 71.0 12 | 56.0 11 | 55.0 18 | 69.0 15 | 57.5 22 | 60.0 16 | 53.0 19 | 58.0 18 | 63.0 13 | 60.0 11 | 71.0 15 | 62 | 20 | 6.48 | BONNET (Réserve) | Saint-Emilion |
21 | 72.0 9 | 72.0 9 | 53.0 16 | 83.5 2 | 73.0 8 | 82.0 7 | 63.0 11 | 67.0 10 | 65.0 12 | 73.0 3 | 70.0 1 | 69.0 16 | 70.2 | 5 | 7.77 | LA TOUR DU PIN-FIGEAC | Saint-Emilion |
2 | 69.0 18 | 62.5 23 | 55.0 12 | 70.0 11 | 61.0 22 | 63.5 16 | 64.0 8 | 65.0 11 | 60.0 16 | 63.0 13 | 51.0 20 | 68.0 17 | 62.7 | 18 | 5.28 | TROTTEVIEILLE | Saint-Emilion |
1 | 64.0 24 | 59.0 24 | 54.0 14 | 52.0 19 | 57.0 24 | 66.0 15 | 54.0 22 | 60.0 12 | 51.0 21 | 62.0 18 | 59.0 13 | 67.0 18 | 58.8 | 23 | 5.12 | FOMBRAUGE | Saint-Emilion |
5 | 71.0 13 | 71.5 11 | 48.0 23 | 52.0 19 | 71.0 10 | 60.5 20 | 60.0 16 | 56.0 15 | 66.5 11 | 67.0 6 | 60.0 11 | 66.0 19 | 62.5 | 19 | 7.38 | LE CASTELOT | Saint-Emilion |
13 | 72.0 9 | 70.5 14 | 58.0 9 | 64.5 12 | 67.0 16 | 88.0 2 | 61.0 14 | 78.0 3 | 74.0 3 | 68.0 4 | 49.0 22 | 66.0 19 | 68 | 9 | 9.51 | TROPLONG-MONDOT | Saint-Emilion |
11 | 72.0 9 | 67.5 19 | 62.0 7 | 55.5 17 | 64.0 19 | 61.0 18 | 64.0 8 | 55.0 16 | 62.0 15 | 62.0 18 | 66.0 3 | 64.0 21 | 62.9 | 17 | 4.48 | SAINT-GEORGES | Saint-Georges-Saint-Emilion |
22 | 73.0 6 | 68.0 18 | 52.0 19 | 84.5 1 | 66.0 17 | 85.5 5 | 49.0 24 | 55.0 16 | 51.0 21 | 64.0 12 | 48.0 24 | 62.0 22 | 63.2 | 16 | 12.43 | CLOS-FOURTET | Saint-Emilion |
4 | 68.0 20 | 65.5 21 | 50.5 22 | 58.5 15 | 59.0 23 | 61.0 18 | 67.0 6 | 51.0 20 | 50.5 23 | 62.0 18 | 53.0 18 | 61.0 23 | 58.9 | 22 | 6.12 | LA GAFFELIERE | Saint-Emilion |
6 | 66.0 21 | 72.0 9 | 57.0 10 | 62.0 14 | 65.0 18 | 68.0 14 | 55.0 19 | 40.0 24 | 50.0 24 | 56.0 24 | 54.0 17 | 58.0 24 | 58.6 | 24 | 8.36 | BEAUSEJOUR-DUFFAU | Saint-Emilion |
Moy | 71 | 71.8 | 56.9 | 65.5 | 70.9 | 72 | 62.3 | 62 | 64.4 | 65.1 | 58.4 | 71.3 | |||||
Ecart | 3.1 | 6 | 6.6 | 11.6 | 8.3 | 11.3 | 7 | 12.1 | 8.6 | 4.6 | 6.2 | 6 |
Les dégustateurs
1 | LE GUERN | Bertrand |
---|---|---|
2 | HALLEE | Daniel |
3 | RIDGWAY | David |
4 | GAURY | Didier |
5 | LALONDRELLE | Yves |
6 | SEGELLE | Alain |
7 | JONCHERES | Jean-Michel |
8 | FRANCHI | Jacques |
9 | DELECU | Michel |
10 | ROMILLAT | Anne |
11 | CADILLON | Pierre |
12 | THUNEVIN | Jean-Luc |