All these wines are out of estimation, ie it is not possible to (mathematicaly) rely their price to their score.

"Good" are those whose price is below the price their score deserves (the "estimated price".
"Naugthy" are those whose price is higher than estimated price.They are (unfortunately for the consumer) more numerous

In 2010, they are very numerous (mostly the second wines), the regression was eliminating so many wines (311 from 390!!!) that I cheated, eliminating a priori the outliers de Tukey (threshold 1.5), they are flagged with an (#)

diff % = (average consumer price - estimated price)/average consumer price * 100, the higher that number, the crazier the price!

Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2012 (best first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Léoville Las-Cases Saint-Julien 95 112.42 311.32 -176.93
 

Naughty 2012 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Bellevue-Mondotte Saint-Emilion 92 135.09 53.3 +60.54
Carruades de Lafite Pauillac 90 128.79 27.11 +78.95
La Chapelle d'Ausone Saint-Emilion 92 129.81 53.3 +58.94
Clos de la Vieille Eglise Pomerol 88 45.23 16.6 +63.3
Clos Dubreuil Saint-Emilion 89 60.25 20.96 +65.21
La Fleur de Gay Pomerol 90 68.38 27.11 +60.35
Girolate Bordeaux 88 40.09 16.6 +58.59
Gracia Saint-Emilion 90 88.47 27.11 +69.36
Lafite Rothschild Pauillac 94 456.62 151.46 +66.83
Pavillon Rouge de Margaux Margaux 91 102.21 36.73 +64.06
Les Pensées de Lafleur Pomerol 91 98.3 36.73 +62.63
Le Petit Cheval Saint-Emilion 91 140.76 36.73 +73.91
Le Pin Pomerol 95 968.4 311.32 +67.85
Quintus Saint-Emilion 90 96.53 27.11 +71.92
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2011 (best first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Doisy-Daëne Barsac 94 35.56 161.15 -353.18
Guiraud Sauternes 94 40.23 161.15 -300.57
Vieux Château Certan Pomerol 96 131.62 1921.36 -1359.78
 

Naughty 2011 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Carruades de Lafite Pauillac 90 152.8 35.21 +76.96
La Mission Haut-Brion blanc Pessac-Léognan 94 796.78 161.15 +79.77
Le Pin Pomerol 94 1116.67 161.15 +85.57
Quintus Saint-Emilion 90 130.15 35.21 +72.95
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2010 (best first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Calon-Ségur Saint-Estèphe 96 82.79 227 -174
Clos Floridène Graves 91 13.41 31.16 -132
Clos Haut-Peyraguey Sauternes 94 41.02 92.15 -125
Doisy-Daëne Barsac 94 33.87 92.15 -172
Domaine de Courteillac Bordeaux supérieur 89 8.41 17.83 -112
Guiraud Sauternes 94 41.24 92.15 -123
Lafaurie-Peyraguey Sauternes 94 40.22 92.15 -129
Léoville Barton Saint-Julien 96 98.54 227 -130
Pontet-Canet Pauillac 97 142.05 377.34 -166
Suduiraut Sauternes 95 64.76 141.95 -119
Vieux Château Certan(#) Pomerol 98 242.79 652.86 -169
 

Naughty 2010 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Angélus(#) Saint-Emilion 95 302.92 141.95 +53
Ausone(#) Saint-Emilion 98 1596.55 652.86 +59
Beauséjour Duffau-Lagarrosse Saint-Emilion 94 241.11 92.15 +62
Belair-Monange Saint-Emilion 93 132.49 62.02 +53
Bellevue-Mondotte Saint-Emilion 94 287.87 92.15 +68
Branon Pessac-Léognan 92 105.56 43.23 +59
Canon Saint-Emilion 93 121.65 62.02 +49
Cap de Mourlin(#) Saint-Emilion 88 29.43 14.12 +52
Le Carillon de l'Angélus(#) Saint-Emilion 90 67.48 23.21 +66
Le Carré(#) Saint-Emilion 91 63.76 31.16 +51
Carruades de Lafite(#) Pauillac 92 269.66 43.23 +84
Certan de May de Certan Pomerol 92 96.58 43.23 +55
La Chapelle d'Ausone Saint-Emilion 93 211.48 62.02 +71
La Chapelle de La Mission Haut-Brion(#) Pessac-Léognan 92 147.05 43.23 +71
Le Clarence de Haut-Brion(#) Pessac-Léognan 92 146.73 43.23 +71
La Clarté de Haut-Brion(#) Pessac-Léognan 90 82.49 23.21 +72
La Clémence(#) Pomerol 89 47.84 17.83 +63
Clos Dubreuil(#) Saint-Emilion 90 78.57 23.21 +70
Clos l'Eglise(#) Pomerol 92 144.31 43.23 +70
La Couspaude(#) Saint-Emilion 90 44.28 23.21 +48
Destieux(#) Saint-Emilion 89 35.69 17.83 +50
Feytit-Clinet(#) Pomerol 91 59.92 31.16 +48
Figeac Saint-Emilion 94 227.16 92.15 +59
La Fleur de Gay(#) Pomerol 90 81.20 23.21 +71
La Fleur Petrus Pomerol 94 207.49 92.15 +56
Les Forts de Latour(#) Pauillac 93 234.56 62.02 +74
Girolate(#) Bordeaux 88 48.88 14.12 +71
La Gomerie(#) Saint-Emilion 91 64.44 31.16 +52
Haut-Brion blanc Pessac-Léognan 97 884.71 377.34 +57
Hosanna Pomerol 94 184.7 92.15 +50
Lascombes Margaux 92 96.07 43.23 +55
Magdelaine(#) Saint-Emilion 91 65.86 31.16 +53
La Mission Haut-Brion blanc(#) Pessac-Léognan 96 785.90 227 +71
La Mission Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 97 829.16 377.34 +54
Monbousquet blanc(#) Bordeaux 91 58.45 31.16 +47
Pape Clément blanc Pessac-Léognan 93 130.67 62.02 +53
Pavie-Decesse Saint-Emilion 93 166.48 62.02 +63
Pavillon Blanc de Margaux Bordeaux 93 133.14 62.02 +53
Pavillon Rouge de Margaux Margaux 93 168.84 62.02 +63
Les Pensées de Lafleur(#) Pomerol 91 122.61 31.16 +75
Le Petit Cheval(#) Saint-Emilion 92 217.58 43.23 +80
Le Petit Lion(#) Saint-Julien 90 48.33 23.21 +52
Le Petit Mouton de Mouton-Rothschild(#) Pauillac 91 155.49 31.16 +80
Petrus(#) Pomerol 98 1692.09 652.86 +61
Pichon Comtesse Pauillac 94 187.25 92.15 +51
Le Pin(#) Pomerol 97 1986.05 377.34 +81
Plince(#) Pomerol 88 28.63 14.12 +51
Le Plus de la Fleur de Boüard Lalande de Pomerol 92 111.42 43.23 +61
Talbot(#) Saint-Julien 91 54.06 31.16 +42
Trottevieille Saint-Emilion 92 90.74 43.23 +52
Valandraud(#) Saint-Emilion 95 288.06 141.95 +51
La Violette(#) Pomerol 94 194.05 92.15 +53
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2009 (best first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Calon-Ségur Saint-Estèphe 96 76.84 229.89 -199.18
Guiraud Sauternes 95 43.03 145.66 -238.51
Raymond-Lafon Sauternes 95 30.61 145.66 -375.86
Suduiraut Sauternes 96 72.35 229.89 -217.75
 

Naughty 2009 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Bellevue-Mondotte Saint-Emilion 94 281.95 95.85 +66
Branon Pessac-Léognan 91 97.56 33.85 +65.3
Carruades de Lafite Pauillac 91 185.22 33.85 +81.72
La Chapelle de La Mission Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 90 80.61 25.59 +68.25
Le Clarence de Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 91 118.57 33.85 +71.45
La Clarté de Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 89 80.29 19.97 +75.13
Gracia Saint-Emilion 91 123.75 33.85 +72.65
Haut-Brion blanc Pessac-Léognan 94 822.05 95.85 +88.34
La Mission Haut-Brion blanc Pessac-Léognan 94 728.53 95.85 +86.84
La Mission Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 96 733.93 229.89 +68.68
Le Petit Cheval Saint-Emilion 91 147.89 33.85 +77.11
Le Petit Mouton de Mouton-Rothschild Pauillac 90 86.64 25.59 +70.46
Le Pin Pomerol 96 1907.24 229.89 +87.95
Le Plus de la Fleur de Boüard Lalande de Pomerol 91 115.04 33.85 +70.58
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2008 (best first)

  

Naughty 2008 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Les Astéries Saint-Emilion 89 65.78 26.38 +59.9
Ausone Saint-Emilion 96 697.14 195.39 +71.97
Bellevue-Mondotte Saint-Emilion 92 179.41 58.88 +67.18
Carruades de Lafite Pauillac 89 61.13 26.38 +56.85
La Chapelle d'Ausone Saint-Emilion 90 104.75 34.18 +67.37
Cheval Blanc Saint-Emilion 95 397.16 142.69 +64.07
La Gomerie Saint-Emilion 88 51.09 20.55 +59.78
Gracia Saint-Emilion 89 79.58 26.38 +66.85
Haut-Brion blanc Pessac-Léognan 94 339.08 105.23 +68.97
Lafleur Pomerol 95 544.67 142.69 +73.8
Laville Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 93 289.95 78.34 +72.98
Magrez Fombrauge Saint-Emilion 90 109.59 34.18 +68.81
Pavie-Decesse Saint-Emilion 91 114.64 44.66 +61.04
Les Pensées de Lafleur Pomerol 89 61.44 26.38 +57.06
Petrus Pomerol 95 1237.81 142.69 +88.47
Le Pin Pomerol 94 1048.69 105.23 +89.97
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2007 (best first)

  

Naughty 2007 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Ausone Saint-Emilion 95 599.69 143.48 +76.07
Bellevue-Mondotte Saint-Emilion 92 211.79 61.19 +71.11
La Chapelle de La Mission Haut-Brion Pessac-Léognan 89 129.77 28.25 +78.23
Cheval Blanc Saint-Emilion 94 467.79 107.02 +77.12
Haut-Brion blanc Pessac-Léognan 95 545.64 143.48 +73.7
Lafleur Pomerol 95 461.42 143.48 +68.9
Magrez Fombrauge Saint-Emilion 90 115.8 36.24 +68.7
Le Petit Cheval Saint-Emilion 88 76.27 22.2 +70.89
Petrus Pomerol 94 546.71 107.02 +80.42
Le Pin Pomerol 94 708.16 107.02 +84.89
Valandraud Saint-Emilion 91 149.26 46.89 +68.59
La Violette Pomerol 91 161.46 46.89 +70.96
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2006 (best first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Clos Floridène blanc Graves 90 12.99 35.29 -171.67
Guiraud Sauternes 93 34.94 91.81 -162.76
 

Naughty 2006 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Les Astéries Saint-Emilion 89 95.58 27.21 +71.53
Ausone Saint-Emilion 95 968.24 202.42 +79.09
Cheval Blanc Saint-Emilion 95 624.69 202.42 +67.6
La Clémence Pomerol 87 56.76 17.59 +69.01
Le Dôme Saint-Emilion 91 125.54 47.11 +62.47
Girolate Bordeaux 87 54.88 17.59 +67.95
Magrez Fombrauge Saint-Emilion 90 124.88 35.29 +71.74
Les Pensées de Lafleur Pomerol 89 70.8 27.21 +61.57
Le Petit Cheval Saint-Emilion 89 103.95 27.21 +73.82
Petrus Pomerol 96 1004.85 315.33 +68.62
Le Pin Pomerol 95 1049.35 202.42 +80.71
La Violette Pomerol 91 159.87 47.11 +70.53
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2005 (best first)

  

Naughty 2005 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Clos de Sarpe Saint-Emilion 89 76.51 21.93 +71.34
Magrez Fombrauge Saint-Emilion 91 168.16 37.54 +77.68
Le Pin Pomerol 95 1088.2 168.97 +84.47
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2004 (best first)

  

Naughty 2004 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Bellevue-Mondotte Saint-Emilion 91 132.38 37.23 +71.88
Clos La Madeleine Saint-Emilion 85 50 13.45 +73.1
La Fleur de Gay Pomerol 88 60.94 20.25 +66.77
Magrez Fombrauge Saint-Emilion 90 119.07 29.68 +75.07
Petrus Pomerol 95 452.74 119.34 +73.64
Le Pin Pomerol 95 465.28 119.34 +74.35
Wines whose primeur price is really crazyPrices

Good 2003 (best first)

  

Naughty 2003 (wores first)

Multiple sorting by pressing Shift key while clicking a column header
vin aoc note € TTC (Prix estimé) diff %
Bellevue-Mondotte Saint-Emilion 91 125.48 27.6 +78
Clos de Sarpe Saint-Emilion 85 54.25 8.56 +84.22
Croix de Labrie Saint-Emilion 89 58.08 18.19 +68.68
L'Evangile Pomerol 90 79.33 22.32 +71.86
Magrez Fombrauge Saint-Emilion 91 97.59 27.6 +71.72
Pavie-Decesse Saint-Emilion 90 80 22.32 +72.1
Le Petit Cheval Saint-Emilion 88 57.36 14.91 +74.01
Petrus Pomerol 96 295.29 88.9 +69.89
Valandraud Saint-Emilion 94 191.09 54.43 +71.52