Classification 1)Scores are "harmonized", ie transformed in such a way that all tasters have the same average and the same standard deviation.
2) Le coefficient of each taster is computed (Chi-2 based), it measures his "agreement" with the panel of tasters. Tasters may be eliminated if this agreement is too weak.
3) Outliers scores of remaining tasters are whipped out.
4) The final score of a wine is obtained by weighting its scores by the tasters's coefficients.
: Workaholics  There are three main classification types
All tasters
Workaholics: those critics who have tasted a "minimal amount" of wines
Critics: those who are not wine merchants
 2012

Raw scores All tasters(405, 10) Workaholics(443, 9) Only critics(405, 10) next2013201120102009200820072006200520042003
Colors are those of harmonized scores
70+75+80+85+90+95+

Clicking on the title of a column triggers sorting according to that column

ScoreEstateAppellationBBBDGMJDJMQTWPYCJPDECJRMJNMTAILJSJLRPRVWS
95
4
Cheval BlancSaint-Emilion94.6
14
93.7
17
95.5
1
95.3
9
95.6
5
94.7
10
92
45
96
3
96.6
2
96.9
1
95
8
95.8
3
94.4
7
93.2
25
93.6
21
94.7
7
94.5
11
94.9
5
95.6
1
94
14
Domaine de Chevalier blancPessac-Léognan97.3
2
91.2
86
95.5
1
89.9
127
94.1
25
93.6
28
94.2
16
93.9
23
94.4
18
92
48
91.8
34
94.9
8
93.7
10
94.7
10
94.7
9
93.8
22
93.7
17
92.6
28
92.7
31
95
4
Haut-BrionPessac-Léognan94.6
14
93.7
17
95.5
1
95.8
3
96.4
1
95.3
8
95.2
6
94.9
16
95.9
7
96.9
1
95
8
95.8
3
93.7
10
94.7
10
95.8
4
96.1
2
93.7
17
96
1
94.7
5
94
14
PavieSaint-Emilion94.6
14
96.1
2
95.5
1
  94.7
10
 96
3
93
34
94.5
17
91.8
34
92.3
47
90.1
168
 94.7
9
93.8
22
94.5
11
93.7
10
 
96
1
PetrusPomerol97.3
2
97.3
1
95.5
1
98.5
1
96.4
1
96.9
1
97.3
2
97
1
95.9
7
95.3
10
96.6
1
96.7
1
95.9
1
95.2
7
97.9
1
96.5
1
95.7
5
96
1
95.6
1
95
4
Le PinPomerol95.9
6
92.4
36
95.5
1
92
58
94.9
13
95.8
3
95.2
6
93.9
23
95.2
12
96.9
1
96.6
1
94
15
93
21
94.2
18
96.8
3
94.7
7
93.7
17
 95.6
1
94
14
Pontet-CanetPauillac92
57
92.4
36
95.5
1
95.8
3
94.1
25
94.1
24
94.2
16
93.9
23
94.4
18
93.6
23
95
8
94.9
8
92.3
52
94.2
18
94.7
9
94.7
7
92.5
57
96
1
 
94
14
AngélusSaint-Emilion93.3
27
94.9
8
94.3
8
92.6
52
95.6
5
94.7
10
93.1
28
94.9
16
94.4
18
93.6
23
93.4
18
92.3
47
92.3
52
91.7
67
93.6
21
92.9
39
94.5
11
93.7
10
 
95
4
AusoneSaint-Emilion95.9
6
94.9
8
94.3
8
96.4
2
95.6
5
94.7
10
96.8
4
96
3
95.2
12
93.6
23
96.6
1
94
15
95.2
2
92.7
34
94.7
9
95.6
4
95.3
7
94.9
5
 
92
52
Beau-Séjour BécotSaint-Emilion92
57
92.4
36
94.3
8
93.7
23
91.1
100
92.4
58
87.8
287
91.9
69
91.5
77
88.7
209
91.8
34
91.4
82
92.3
52
87.2
225
91.5
81
91.5
73
93.3
29
92.6
28
90.8
99
93
30
Domaine de ChevalierPessac-Léognan93.3
27
92.4
36
94.3
8
93.7
23
92.6
51
93.6
28
91
93
91.9
69
93
34
91.2
98
91.8
34
93.2
25
93
21
93.2
25
93.6
21
91.1
83
93.3
29
92.6
28
91.8
53
95
4
L'Eglise-ClinetPomerol97.3
2
93.7
17
94.3
8
 94.9
13
95.8
3
97.3
2
 93
34
92
48
 96.7
1
95.2
2
96.2
2
94.7
9
96.1
2
96.9
2
 94.7
5
94
14
L'EvangilePomerol92
57
96.1
2
94.3
8
94.2
14
91.8
72
93.6
28
95.2
6
96
3
92.2
62
93.6
23
95
8
94.9
8
92.3
52
94.7
10
94.7
9
94.7
7
92.1
63
 93.7
19
91
83
de FieuzalPessac-Léognan90.7
108
90
155
94.3
8
91.5
87
90.3
145
91.3
99
91
93
90.8
88
88.6
253
90.4
117
90.2
88
89.7
173
90.9
139
92.2
38
91.5
81
90.2
118
90.5
133
91.5
54
88.9
202
96
1
Haut-Brion blancPessac-Léognan98.6
1
96.1
2
94.3
8
93.1
32
94.1
25
96.4
2
98.4
1
97
1
97.4
1
96.9
1
95
8
94.9
8
93.7
10
96.7
1
97.9
1
95.6
4
97.7
1
93.7
10
94.7
5
94
14
Lafite RothschildPauillac94.6
14
93.7
17
94.3
8
93.7
23
93.3
37
94.7
10
94.2
16
93.9
23
95.9
7
96.1
7
95
8
93.2
25
93.7
10
93.2
25
93.6
21
92.9
39
93.3
29
94.9
5
94.7
5
96
1
LafleurPomerol95.9
6
94.9
8
94.3
8
 94.9
13
95.8
3
96.8
4
96
3
96.6
2
95.3
10
 93.2
25
 95.2
7
95.8
4
94.7
7
92.9
37
  
90
148
Latour-Martillac blancPessac-Léognan90.7
108
 94.3
8
89.3
157
88.8
223
88.5
263
89.9
173
87.8
272
91.5
77
88.7
209
88.6
165
91.4
82
92.3
52
93.2
25
  91.3
99
90.4
100
 
94
14
MargauxMargaux94.6
14
94.9
8
94.3
8
94.2
14
95.6
5
94.7
10
93.1
28
94.9
16
96.6
2
95.3
10
96.6
1
94
15
93.7
10
94.7
10
93.6
21
93.8
22
92.9
37
93.7
10
94.7
5
93
30
Smith Haut Lafitte blancPessac-Léognan95.9
6
92.4
36
94.3
8
 92.6
51
93.6
28
92
45
93.9
23
 90.4
117
91.8
34
93.2
25
91.6
100
91.7
67
95.8
4
93.8
22
93.7
17
91.5
54
93.7
19
coeff1.11.10.90.81.21.30.91.31.10.80.90.90.80.81.11.210.80.9
rang55101531101515101015155391510
Search: Goto Page: / 23 443 Rows